Cooking, Collecting, and Connecting to Cast Iron

Vollrath #3

When you put so much energy into growing your own food you want to make sure it tastes great when you cook it.  We discovered long ago that all foods taste better when cooked in cast iron.  Whether its a skillet, dutch oven, or a griddle, cast iron always gives that food a little extra flavor, and is even a great weight.

We started our journey into cast iron in the way that most do.  We purchased a brand new Lodge skillet and brought it home, with the intent to recreate all of the dishes on the cover of mother earth news.  We learned quickly that cast iron cooking is a different animal.  Skillets need to be seasoned prior to use, and it takes much longer to get them to temperature.  Seasoning is a very straight forward process.  We get the pan warm in the oven and then apply a very thin coat of crisco to the pan.  We wipe the excess oil off and place the pan upside down in the oven at 350 for 30 min. After 30 min we wipe the excess oil off again and then bake for an additional 30 min.  After that, we shut the oven down and let the pan cool inside.  More recently we have started to use lard from our home-raised pigs to season our pans and it works great.  This is a more traditional oil to use and it makes us happy to use another product from our homestead.  We also learned that cast iron may take a long time to heat up, but once it does it maintains a wonderful even heat.  The more we cook with our pans the more the seasoning builds up and the better they work.  Our cast iron pot has never made a bad meal.

When I come in from the cold and see it simmering away on the stove I know I’m in for a treat.  Soups, stews, and chili all are kicked up a notch when they are cooked in the cast iron pot.  The pot is also wonderful for deep frying hand cut french fries, onion rings, and my personal favorite, Tostones. (we have a blog in the archives on making these)

More recently we added a biscuit pan that makes the flakiest and most evenly cooked biscuits you ever tasted.  We know that our cast iron cookware will be around long after we are gone.

After the fall harvest and hunting season, when the days grow short a secret danger lurks on the homestead.  That danger is boredom and online estate auctions.  Recently we purchased a few antique cast iron pans from the estate of a 104 year old WWII veteran.  We purchased 3 pans and one griddle for $40, with the expectation of using them to cook.

Little did we know that there was a whole world of antique cast iron collecting out there.  As soon as we picked up our pans, the research began.  If you love solving a good mystery as much as I do, you will love trying to find the origins of your pan.  After a lot of searching and a few messages exchanged with a cast iron guru, we found that we had  Wagner, Vollrath, and Griswold pans.  The griddle is still a bit of a mystery . img_4641

We even were told about a cast iron collectors group on facebook.  We set out to strip and restore our pans.  Again there is a lot of varying info out there so we asked the guru and have been using for a reference.  We started out by cleaning our pans with oven cleaner, some pans responded well, others did not. img_4686

Next we made and electrolysis tub using a battery charger, this worked great for removing rust and is doing a decent job on getting the baked on gunk off of the pans.img_4680

Once the pans are stripped, we season them.  Once seasoned, the vintage pans are so beautiful you almost don’t want to cook with them, almost. img_4660

It is interesting that the older pans are much thinner and lighter than today’s pans.  Our Griswold pan appears to be not only the most recognizable, but also the most valuable.  I dare say we may have now been bit by the collecting bug, but time will tell.  The journey we have taken into cast iron seems to have taken us to the same place that all of our other journeys take us, to the past.   It is visions of the past and a simpler life that  attracted us to homesteading, and it is that vision which also pushes us forward.  Cast iron cookware is so durable and long lasting that it has allowed us to actually touch the past, as there is something special about cooking in old cast iron pan.  Our meals are now connected to all of the meals these pans have cooked.  We are happy to carry on the tradition of cast iron cooking. 


  • I love my cast iron. But since I live in a tiny apartment and hope to be in my van/bus soon I can’t keep a lot. I’ve widdled it down to just two: a large dutch over and a large deep skillet, I think it’s 9 or 10. I can use the skillet as a lid for the dutch oven because I don’t have one for it. It makes a nice little oven!. The only other thing I cook with is a nice heavy stainless steel sauce pot. Other than that I’m all cast iron.


    • What a great idea for the lid I never thought of that!! We have acquired quite a few over the years but we started with just one pan hopefully you get into a bigger space and can get some more it’s so addictive

      Liked by 1 person

      • I had to make a lid that way. The big dutch oven didn’t have a lid. got it second hand from an amish lady. Instead of paying a bunch of money for an actual lid I just used what I had.

        I’ve actually had more cast iron but since I’m widdling my life and belongings down in order to go tiny I had to pick which ones I really need. I figure I have to have the dutch oven, and I can fry or cook whatever, including corn bread , in the deep skillet. Not sure what they’re actually called but that’s what I call it. Got it also second hand at a flea market. It’s a wagner. I saw it glistening in the sun on the table and was like, holy crap I don’t care how much it costs it’s mine. It was $8. freckin’ dollars! I found it in perfect condition. the dutch oven is a Keilen LTD I think? That’s what it looks like on the bottom of it. Not sure. It’s also very awesome. 😀


      • Wow 8 bucks is a great deal !!! I suppose it doesn’t matter what it says on the bottom as long as it works

        Liked by 1 person

      • I’ve heard that wagner is good. And this particular one is really good. I’ve never heard of keinlen but like you said if it works it works. lol The only ones I don’t really care for are the modern lodge cast iron. The “pre seasoning” is sort of funky. It’s like little pebbles all over the surface.

        Liked by 1 person

      • The older ones are much smoother

        Liked by 1 person

  • Reblogged this on two branches homestead and commented:

    tis the season to give cast iron


  • Aw I love this post and the references to the past and living more simply! I just bought my first cast iron pan this year–from Lodge and it cost a pretty penny. I wanted to help boost my iron levels. It is really heavy though and I struggle to lift it one-handed lol but I have noticed a difference in the flavours. I did a light season with butter as I wasn’t sure what to use but these are great tips so thanks for sharing, guys! I would love a cast iron dutch oven. Def. am going to slowly build my collection over the next few years as stainless steel and non-stick annoy me so much and don’t last. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s